Brent Swings Between About $102 and $105 Monday After Trump Announces Russia-Ukraine 'Energy Ceasefire'; Energy Department Loaned Up to 4 Million Barrels of Reserve Crude to Exxon and BP on Saturday After Isaias
Brent was down $1.54 at $103.18 in early Asian trading, then reversed; Reuters had it at $105.41 by 0923 GMT. A drone strike on a tanker off Oman and a projectile strike near Hormuz kept Gulf risk in focus. The Kremlin has not confirmed the truce. U.S. stock futures were mixed and the bond market was closed for Columbus Day.
Two Brent prices, three hours apart
Early Monday in Asia, Brent crude was down $1.54, or 1.47%, at $103.18 a barrel. U.S. crude (WTI) fell the same $1.54, to $90.31[1]. Brent is the global benchmark. WTI is the U.S. one, and it traded about $13 lower.
Then the drop reversed. Brent traded as high as about $105.63 and as low as about $102.33, a range of roughly $3 in one session. That range comes from Mitrade, a retail broker with a commercial interest in trading activity[3]. By 0923 GMT, Reuters had Brent at $105.41, up 0.7%, and WTI at $92.42[2].
So the "$1.54 fall" in many recaps describes one early moment. It isn't where the session was heading. Reuters' own story shows this. Its early version said oil fell "on hopes" of a ceasefire. Its later version was headlined "Oil prices fluctuate on Trump's Russian diesel comments, attacks on Saudi"[2].
A ceasefire one side announced
The trigger was a Truth Social post from President Trump on Sunday, October 11. It declared an "ENERGY CEASEFIRE" between Russia and Ukraine, in effect immediately. "Both parties have agreed," he wrote[4].
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy called the deal "news for me." He said Ukraine would agree if Russia did. "Ukraine wants peace," he said. "The question is whether Russia does." He pointed to Russian drones and a strike on a Kharkiv power plant after the announcement[5][6]. On Monday he accused Russia of violating the truce, citing attacks on Naftogaz gas facilities in the Kharkiv region[25].
The Kremlin has not confirmed anything. Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said "contacts are ongoing" and declined to say what the truce covers[25]. A White House official told Axios the deal may cover only oil refineries[7]. The administration's argument is that announcing a deal publicly puts pressure on both sides to keep it[4]. A similar pause in March 2025 broke down[17].
Why a Europe-focused truce moves a Gulf-priced market
Ukraine's drones have hit Russian refineries. Damaged refineries make less diesel to sell abroad. A real halt would let Russia repair them and export more fuel, which would ease global supply. That is why traders sold at first.
But repairs take time. The National, a UAE-linked outlet, reports Russian diesel exports fell from 706,000 barrels a day in January to almost nothing in September[15]. Any gain would come slowly. The same piece quotes analysts calling the measures "Band-Aids" in a market that burns close to 29 million barrels of diesel a day[15].
Each side has a stake. Russia wants to fix its refineries and restore export income. It also gains from a U.S. Treasury license, running through April 7, 2027, for a diesel deal worth more than 300,000 tons at once[16]. Ukraine wants its grid protected before winter. It also doesn't want to give up its drone strikes on refineries, among its strongest tools, without something in return[15]. If Kyiv refuses, it risks blame for higher prices. If it agrees and Moscow doesn't comply, it loses leverage[6]. Kyiv also objects to the diesel deal, arguing that easing sanctions on Russian fuel pays for Moscow's war[16].
What keeps Brent above $100
The floor under prices is in the Gulf. On Sunday, a drone hit the tanker MT Petro Dolphin near Sohar, Oman. The UK Maritime Trade Operations agency (UKMTO) reclassified the incident as an attack. Syrian state outlet SANA reported two Indian sailors missing[13][14]. A projectile also hit the MT Valthera in the Strait of Hormuz[13].
For the crews, the issue is safe passage. For the market, it means higher insurance and freight costs. Houthi strikes on Saudi targets add to the pressure[2]. Goldman Sachs raised its December Brent forecast to $90 from $85. It cited a risk premium of just over $20 a barrel[2].
Gulf and Indian outlets put these attacks at the top of their coverage. That explains why many analysts say a Europe-focused truce can't offset Middle East risk[1][2].
The reserve loan that isn't a release
On Saturday, October 10, the Energy Department said it would lend up to 4 million barrels from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. ExxonMobil and BP can each borrow up to 2 million barrels to keep refineries running after Hurricane Isaias. Both must repay the oil, plus extra barrels, next year[8].
This is an exchange, not a sale. The reserve is crude stored in salt caverns in Texas and Louisiana. The company returns the barrels later with a "premium" of extra oil. Energy Secretary Chris Wright says that saves taxpayers money and refills the reserve over time[8][19]. Fox Business has described exchanges the same way, as getting about 1.25 barrels back for each one lent.
Critics point to how low the reserve already is. Fox Business reported 349.2 million barrels in early June, near 1983 levels. Each loan leaves less on hand until the oil returns in 2027[20]. India's WION headlined the move a "release" and dropped "up to." A reader could take that as a sale or as barrels already delivered[18].
The size matters too. Before Isaias hit, operators shut in 1,458,814 barrels a day, or 71.51% of Gulf oil output[9]. The 4 million barrel loan equals less than three days of that lost production. It's meant to keep two companies' refineries running, not to lower global prices. Undamaged platforms usually restart within days, but no official count of restarts was found[9][24].
Same event, different headlines
Fox News wrote "both sides agree" in its own voice, though Moscow hadn't confirmed and Kyiv said it learned of the deal from the news[4]. NBC News used "claims" and a "but" structure that put Ukraine's rebuttal in the headline[6]. CNBC tied the diesel deal to the November midterms and called the price relief small[21]. Al Jazeera led with Zelenskyy's "violation" charge, which treats the truce as being in force while putting Kyiv's account first[5].
WION's "release" framing was the loosest on the reserve[18]. The National took a skeptical, Gulf-supply angle[15]. Reuters' headlines changed as the day moved, which shows how fast the early snapshot went stale.
Elsewhere, U.S. stock futures were mixed. Dow and S&P 500 contracts were up about 0.1%, and the Nasdaq 100 contract was slightly lower[10]. The bond market was closed for Columbus Day, while stocks traded[11]. Big banks report Tuesday, and September inflation data comes later this week.
The open question is whether Moscow ever says yes. Until it does, the truce rests on one side's announcement, and Brent will keep following the Gulf.
Summary
Oil prices swung on Monday, October 12, 2026. Early in Asian trading, Brent crude, the global benchmark, fell $1.54, or 1.47%, to $103.18 a barrel. U.S. crude (WTI) fell the same $1.54, to $90.31[1]. The trigger was President Trump's Sunday post that Russia and Ukraine had agreed to stop attacking each other's energy sites[1][4]. The drop did not hold. Brent traded as high as about $105.63 and as low as about $102.33[3]. By 0923 GMT, Reuters had it at $105.41, up 0.7%, and WTI at $92.42, as tanker attacks, Houthi strikes on Saudi targets and Trump's Russian diesel remarks competed for traders' attention[2]. So the '$1.54 fall' describes one moment early in the day. It is not where the session was heading.
Whether the truce exists is the main dispute. Trump wrote that 'both parties have agreed'[4]. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said the deal was 'news for me.' He said Ukraine would agree if Russia did, but that Russian drones and strikes kept coming, including on a Kharkiv power plant[5][6]. On Monday he accused Russia of violating the truce, citing attacks on Naftogaz gas facilities in the Kharkiv region[25]. The Kremlin did not confirm. Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said 'contacts are ongoing' and declined to say what the truce covers[25]. A White House official told Axios the deal may cover only oil refineries[7].
Separately, the Energy Department said on Saturday, October 10, that it would lend up to 4 million barrels from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. ExxonMobil and BP can each borrow up to 2 million barrels to keep their refineries running after Hurricane Isaias. Both must pay the oil back, plus extra barrels, next year[8]. Before the storm hit, operators had shut about 1.46 million barrels a day of Gulf oil output. That was 71.51% of the region's production[9]. U.S. stock futures were mixed. The Dow and S&P 500 contracts were up slightly and the Nasdaq 100 contract was down slightly. The bond market was closed for Columbus Day. Big banks report on Tuesday, and September inflation data comes later this week[10][11][12].
The Event
Trump posted on Sunday, October 11, that an 'ENERGY CEASEFIRE' between Russia and Ukraine was in effect immediately[4]. By 0154 GMT Monday, Brent crude futures were down $1.54 at $103.18 and WTI was down $1.54 at $90.31[1]. Brent then swung between roughly $102 and $105 and was at $105.41 by 0923 GMT[2][3]. On Sunday, a drone hit a tanker near Sohar, Oman. A projectile hit a second tanker in the Strait of Hormuz[13][14]. On Saturday, October 10, the Energy Department approved loans of up to 4 million barrels of reserve crude to ExxonMobil and BP[8].
Undisputed Facts
- Trump announced an 'energy ceasefire' on Truth Social on Sunday, October 11, saying 'Both parties have agreed'[4].
- By 0154 GMT Monday, Brent was down $1.54 (1.47%) at $103.18 and WTI was down $1.54 (1.68%) at $90.31[1].
- By 0923 GMT Monday, Reuters reported Brent at $105.41 (+0.7%) and WTI at $92.42 (+0.6%)[2].
- The Kremlin did not confirm the truce; Peskov said 'contacts are ongoing'[25]. Zelenskyy said Ukraine would agree if Russia did[5][6].
- The Energy Department will lend ExxonMobil and BP up to 2 million barrels each. Both must return the oil plus additional barrels next year[8].
- Before Isaias made landfall, operators shut in 1,458,814 barrels a day, or 71.51% of Gulf oil output[9].
- The UK Maritime Trade Operations agency (UKMTO) reclassified an incident near Sohar, Oman, as an attack after confirming a drone hit a tanker[13][14].
- The U.S. bond market was closed Monday for Columbus Day. Stock markets were open[11].
The Pressure
Strip away the moralizing and blame. What structural realities persist regardless of which narrative wins?
- Why the truce matters to oil prices
- Ukraine's drones have hit Russian refineries. Damaged refineries make less diesel to export. A real halt would let Russia repair them and sell more fuel abroad, which would ease global supply. That is why traders sold. But repairs take time, and The National reports Russian diesel exports were near zero in September, so any gain would come slowly[15].
- How a reserve 'exchange' works
- The reserve is crude stored in salt caverns in Texas and Louisiana. In an exchange, the government does not sell oil. It lends barrels. The company later returns them plus extra 'premium' barrels. Supporters say this fills short-term gaps at no cost to taxpayers and grows the reserve[8][19]. Critics note the reserve was already low: Fox Business reported 349.2 million barrels in early June, near 1983 levels. Every loan also leaves less on hand until the oil comes back in 2027[20].
- Gulf risk sets the floor
- Brent has stayed above $100 because of the Iran conflict, tanker strikes and attacks on Saudi targets. A Europe-focused truce does little to change that[2][13].
Material realityTwo kinds of crude are at play. Brent is the global benchmark. WTI is the U.S. benchmark, and it traded about $13 lower on Monday[1]. Hurricane Isaias took out about 1.46 million barrels a day of Gulf output before landfall. Undamaged platforms usually restart within days, but no official count of restarted output as of Monday was found[9][24]. The 4 million barrel loan is small next to that. It equals less than three days of the oil shut in at the peak, and it is meant to keep two companies' refineries running, not to lower global prices[8][9]. On stocks, the Dow and S&P 500 futures were up about 0.1% and the Nasdaq 100 futures were down slightly. So 'slightly higher' fits only part of the market[10].
Narrative as a weaponThe White House wants the truce seen as a done deal that brings prices down, and friendly outlets repeat 'both sides agree.' Kyiv wants its doubts and its role in the deal recognized, and many U.S. left-leaning and Qatari outlets lead with Zelenskyy's rebuttal. Moscow says almost nothing. That leaves others to describe its position, while it gains from the diesel license. Gulf and Indian media keep attention on Hormuz and the tanker crews. Market recaps that headline the early '$1.54 fall' freeze a moment that the rest of the session partly reversed. The reserve loan was announced Saturday, not Monday, and is a loan of 'up to' 4 million barrels, not a sale.
How Each Side Sees It
Each major actor’s view — how it frames things, its underlying incentive, and how it’s materially affected. Tap a side to read it.
Frames it asThe administration says it is using every tool it has to lower fuel prices. That includes diplomacy to stop strikes on energy sites and short-term loans from the reserve. On the reserve, Energy Secretary Chris Wright says the deals require Exxon and BP to return more barrels than they borrow. He says that saves taxpayers money and refills the reserve over time[8][19]. On the truce, the administration's argument is that announcing a deal publicly puts pressure on both sides to keep it[4].
WhyGasoline and diesel prices ahead of the November midterms. CNBC reports the diesel deal offers little price relief in that window[21].
Impact on themIf the truce holds, the White House gets credit for lower prices. If strikes go on, its claim of agreement is open to challenge, as happened when a similar pause in March 2025 broke down[17].
Frames it asKyiv says it wants peace, but Russia must show it first. 'Ukraine wants peace. The question is whether Russia does,' Zelenskyy said. He pointed to Russian drones over Ukraine and the strike on a Kharkiv power plant after the announcement[5][6]. Kyiv also objected to the U.S.-Russia diesel deal. It argues that easing sanctions on Russian fuel pays for Moscow's war[16].
WhyUkraine wants to protect its power grid before winter. It also wants to keep the pressure from its drone strikes on Russian refineries, which are among its strongest tools, unless Russia gives something in return[15].
Impact on themIf Ukraine refuses, it risks being blamed for higher oil prices. If it agrees and Russia does not comply, it gives up a key source of leverage[6].
Frames it asMoscow has said little in public. Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said 'contacts are ongoing' and that the Kremlin would say more when it had something to report[25]. Its position is built around the diesel deal. Under it, Russia would supply more than 300,000 tons of diesel at once, under a U.S. Treasury license running through April 7, 2027[16].
WhyTo repair its refineries and restore fuel export income while winning U.S. sanctions relief[15][16].
Impact on themThe National reports Russian diesel exports fell from 706,000 barrels a day in January to almost nothing in September, so a halt to Ukrainian drone strikes on its refineries matters a great deal[15].
Frames it asTraders sold on the headline, then bought back. Many analysts say the truce cannot offset Middle East risk. That risk includes the tanker strikes near Oman and Hormuz and Yemeni attacks on Saudi targets[1][2]. Goldman Sachs raised its December Brent forecast to $90 from $85, citing a risk premium of just over $20 a barrel[2]. The National quotes analysts calling the measures 'Band-Aids' in a market that uses close to 29 million barrels of diesel a day[15].
WhyTo price the real chance of supply coming back, not the announcement.
Impact on themWider price swings. Mitrade, a retail broker, put Brent's range at about $3 in one session, from roughly $105.63 to $102.33[3].
Frames it asTo Gulf and Indian outlets, the main story is the attacks on shipping. A drone hit the tanker MT Petro Dolphin near Sohar, and Syrian state outlet SANA reported two Indian sailors missing. A projectile also hit the MT Valthera in the Strait of Hormuz[13][14].
WhySafe passage through the Gulf and safety for crews.
Impact on themHigher insurance and freight costs, and a floor under Brent prices above $100[2].
Like this article?
The Bias Ledger average rating 3.3
The same story, as framed by outlets across the spectrum, ordered least to most biased. The bias score (1 = straight, 10 = heavily spun) is an AI assessment of that framing — click an outlet to see its track record. The tell is the word choice or omission that reveals the angle.
| Outlet | Vantage | Bias | How they frame it | The tell |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reuters | U.S./international center wire | 2 | Oil falls on hopes Russia-Ukraine energy ceasefire will boost supplies (early version); later 'Oil prices fluctuate on Trump's Russian diesel comments, attacks on Saudi' | The early version called the move 'hopes,' not a done deal, and timestamped the price (0154 GMT). The later rewrite shows how fast the early snapshot went stale. |
| NBC News | U.S. center-left | 3 | Trump claims 'energy ceasefire,' but Ukraine says Russia keeps striking its energy facilities | Uses 'claims' and a 'but' structure that puts the rebuttal in the headline. That is fair attribution, but it leans toward doubt. |
| Al Jazeera | Qatari state-funded | 3 | Zelenskyy says Russia violated energy truce announced by Trump | Attributes the 'violation' to Zelenskyy in the headline and notes his 'news to him' reaction and that the Kremlin had not responded. The Kyiv-first framing still treats the truce as in force. |
| The National | UAE state-linked (Abu Dhabi-owned) | 3 | Why Trump's Russia-Ukraine energy ceasefire may offer oil markets little relief | An explainer that leans on analysts, with a skeptical angle that keeps Gulf supply risk at the center. |
| WION | Indian, privately owned (Zee group) | 4 | US taps strategic petroleum reserve, releasing 4 million barrels after hurricane Isaias disruption | Calls a loan to two firms a 'release' and drops 'up to.' Readers could take it as a sale, or as barrels already delivered. |
| Fox News | U.S. right | 5 | Trump announces Russia-Ukraine energy ceasefire, both sides agree | Presents 'both sides agree' as fact in its own voice, though Moscow had not confirmed and Kyiv said it learned of the deal from the news. |
References
- Oil falls on hopes Russia-Ukraine energy ceasefire will boost supplies (early version) — Reuters · International wire service, commercially owned (Thomson Reuters); center
- Oil prices fluctuate on Trump's Russian diesel comments, attacks on Saudi (updated version, 0923 GMT) — Reuters · International wire service, commercially owned (Thomson Reuters); center
- Brent swings $105.63 to $102.33 as Gulf risk meets an 'energy ceasefire' — Mitrade · Retail trading broker; commercial interest in trading activity
- Trump announces Russia-Ukraine energy ceasefire, both sides agree — Fox News · U.S. right; Fox Corporation (Murdoch family)
- Zelenskyy says Russia violated energy truce announced by Trump — Al Jazeera · Funded by the Qatari state
- Trump claims 'energy ceasefire,' but Ukraine says Russia keeps striking its energy facilities — NBC News · U.S. center-left; Comcast/NBCUniversal
- Trump's Russia-Ukraine Energy Ceasefire May Only Cover Oil Refineries — OilPrice.com · Energy-industry trade site; commercially funded
- U.S. to open strategic reserve to address supply disruptions due to hurricane — Associated Press · Nonprofit cooperative wire; center (carried by WTOK, Gray Media)
- About 71.5% of US Gulf oil production shut in ahead of Hurricane Isaias — Reuters · International wire service; center (carried by BOE Report)
- US stock futures muted as oil stays above $100 ahead of earnings — Reuters · International wire service; center (carried by Investing.com)
- Is the Stock Market Closed on Columbus Day/Indigenous Peoples' Day? — Yahoo Finance · Commercial financial portal (Apollo-owned); center
- Stock Market Today: S&P 500, Dow Jones Futures Gain Even as Iran Flags 'Inadequate' US Response to Peace — Benzinga · Commercial trader-oriented financial media
- Crude oil tanker attacked off Oman coast, UK maritime agency says — Reuters · International wire service; center (carried by Yahoo News)
- Drone attack hits oil tanker near Sohar Port in Oman, two sailors missing — SANA · Syrian state news agency
- Why Trump's Russia-Ukraine energy ceasefire may offer oil markets little relief — The National · Abu Dhabi state-linked ownership; UAE
- Trump says Russia, Ukraine agree energy ceasefire two days after Russian diesel deal — investingLive · Commercial trader-news site
- Trump and Putin announce pause on Russia-Ukraine energy infrastructure strikes — Axios · U.S. center; Cox Enterprises-owned
- US taps strategic petroleum reserve, releasing 4 million barrels after hurricane Isaias disruption — WION · Indian, Zee Media group; nationalist-leaning commercial broadcaster
- Energy Department Initiates Additional Strategic Petroleum Reserve Emergency Exchange to Stabilize Global Oil Supply — U.S. Department of Energy · U.S. government (Trump administration) primary source
- Strategic Petroleum Reserve nears Reagan-era lows amid Iran conflict — Fox Business · U.S. right-leaning business news; Fox Corporation
- Trump's diesel deal offers little price relief deal ahead of midterms — CNBC · U.S. center business news; Versant/NBCUniversal lineage
- Oil prices drop as stocks rise after Trump touts 'energy ceasefire' — Euronews · European broadcaster, privately owned (Alpac Capital), EU-funded partly
- Trump declares 'energy ceasefire' between Russia and Ukraine; Zelenskyy is waiting for details — CNBC · U.S. center business news
- MMA Monitors Gulf of America Oil and Gas Activities in Response to Hurricane Isaias — Marine Minerals Administration (BSEE site) · U.S. government primary source
- Zelensky Accuses Russia of Breaking Energy Ceasefire as Kremlin Says Talks Ongoing — The Moscow Times · Independent Russian-language outlet now publishing from exile; critical of the Kremlin